My sister was really craving oysters, and when we came to Fish in 2009, we loved the bluepoint special oyster deal of $8 for 6 oysters and a house wine or P.B.R. Since my cousin was in town from San Francisco, we decided it'd be a great time to check the place out once again. We got to the restaurant at 7:30pm on Friday night and waited an hour and a half before we were seated.
A nice surprise: the $8 oyster deal has not changed! The con: the oysters were so, so bland. It was like they had all been dunked in tap water until all flavor had been zapped out.
Fried Calamari with marinara sauce $13. Hot and freshly fried, but could have used more seasoning.
Lobster Feast (market price) $20, includes 2 sides. We chose fries and corn. My sister and I shared this, and halfway through, we ordered another lobster. Totally worth the hour-plus wait.
Our second lobster that we destroyed very quickly $14. After ordering the Lobster Feast, one can order another lobster without the sides for $14. This second one was substantially larger than the first.
280 Bleecker Street (between Jones Street & Commerce Street)
New York, NY 10014
Phone number: (212)727-2879
View Larger Map