I'm finally making more of an effort to venture out to restaurants I've never been to. If it were up to me, I'd happily stick to the places I know and love, but alas, it'd be boring for all if my blog entries were something like "Mermaid Inn Revisited" over and over again...
Last weekend I spent a decent chunk of time searching for brunch places with a great eggs benedict on Yelp. Elephant & Castle has great reviews, so I thought I'd give it a shot.
My friend and I arrived at 11:00am on Saturday morning and we were seated right away (being an early-riser really does pay off in this city).
Chewy, cold bread. At least a day-old, perhaps?
Eggs Benedict on Potato Pancakes $10.50. One of the Elephant & Castle's most popular brunch dishes. We were both surprised. I really can't name one thing special about it. Instead of an english muffin under the ham and egg, there was a hash brown/ potato hybrid. Yes, that doesn't happen often, but it didn't exactly enhance the dish a whole lot. The hollandaise sauce also lacked flavor. There was one piece of broccoli on the side. That was a bit strange, too. Although I don't like it when there's no side with an eggs benedict, I can understand that, but to instead put one piece of broccoli? C'mon now...
Roasted Portobello Mushroom with Mozzarella, Tomato, Arugula, and Basil Mayo $9.50. All the toasted bread for sandwiches are toasted twice. I'm not sure why the bread is toasted twice, but the result was that it was so hard that I thought my teeth were going to chip off.
We were both so disappointed with this brunch. After we walked out of the restaurant I asked my friend what she thought of it and she said "unmemorable". That pretty much sums it up.
68 Greenwich Avenue (between 11th Street and South 7th Avenue)
New York, NY 10011
Phone number: (212)243-1400
View Larger Map